IEC 61111 vs ASTM D178: Which Insulating Mat Standard Applies to Your Project?

November 4, 2026 7 min readInsulation & Standards

The two standards share one voltage ladder and disagree on thickness — 3 mm versus 6.4 mm at the same class. The class-by-class comparison, the Type and Category systems, and how to write a spec that survives inspection.

One tender says "insulating matting to ASTM D178, Class 2, 6.4 mm". Another says "IEC 61111, Class 2, 3 mm".

Same class. Same voltage. More than twice the thickness. Both conforming.

That single pair of numbers explains most of the confusion around these two standards, so start there.

1. The voltage ladder is identical. The thickness is not.

ClassMax use ACAC proof testWithstand testIEC 61111 recommendedASTM D178
01.0 kV5.0 kV10.0 kV2.0 mm3.2 mm
17.5 kV10.0 kV20.0 kV2.0 mm4.8 mm
217.0 kV20.0 kV30.0 kV3.0 mm6.4 mm
326.5 kV30.0 kV40.0 kV4.0 mm9.5 mm
436.0 kV40.0 kV50.0 kV5.0 mm12.7 mm

Read down the first four columns: they are the same in both standards, number for number. Class 2 is 17 kV maximum use in either book. The proof test is 20 kV in either book. The withstand test is 30 kV in either book.

Now read the last two columns. IEC 61111 asks for 3 mm at Class 2. ASTM D178 asks for 6.4 mm.

So the two standards agree completely on what the mat has to survive, and disagree by a factor of two on how much rubber you use getting there. If you are buying to a class and a voltage, the standard you name decides the thickness — and therefore the weight, the freight cost and the roll count.

One consequence worth stating plainly: a millimetre figure on its own cannot be checked against anything. "6.4 mm" is a conforming Class 2 mat under ASTM and a Class 3 mat under IEC. I have written about that trap separately — why thickness does not map to voltage — so I will not repeat it here.

2. Why the two scales differ

IEC 61111 gives a recommended thickness per class and a separate maximum allowed thickness. Class 2 recommends 3 mm and allows up to 8 mm; Class 4 recommends 5 mm and allows up to 14 mm. That is a window, not a nominal dimension.

ASTM D178 gives one thickness per class — 3.2, 4.8, 6.4, 9.5, 12.7 mm — spanning a range of 3.2 to 12.7 mm. There is no window to move inside.

Both are internally consistent. The difference is editorial as much as technical: one standard says "at least this much, comfortably inside that band", the other says "this thickness". Since the test voltages are identical, the gap is not in what the mat must withstand. It is in how much material each standard expects you to spend to get there.

3. ASTM puts material performance in Type. IEC puts it in Category.

This is the part that gets lost when someone compares the two by thickness alone.

Under ASTM D178, Type I is the default supply grade. Type II covers the higher-performance elastomers, and the letters after it can be specified singly or in combination: IIA for ozone, IIB for flame retardance, IIC for oil. The numbers behind them are testable, which is what makes them useful on a purchase order:

  • Water absorption: Type I ≤ 1.5 %, Type II ≤ 3 %
  • Tensile strength ≥ 4.83 MPa (700 psi), elongation at break ≥ 250 %
  • After 168 hours at 70 °C, tensile strength retains at least 50 % of its original value
  • IIB: char height ≤ 12.7 mm after a 30-second flame test
  • IIC: volume swell ≤ 4 % after oil immersion

IEC 61111 handles the same idea through categories rather than Type letters — Category C, for example, covers extreme low temperature, and is tested as a special property rather than as part of the base requirement.

The practical point: two suppliers can both quote "Class 2, conforming" and deliver different material. The class fixes the voltage. Type or Category fixes whether the mat survives your site.

4. Tolerances are not written the same way

ASTM D178 states thickness tolerance as ±0.8 to 1.2 mm depending on class, and width tolerance as ±13 to 25 mm depending on class and width. So a 6.4 mm Class 2 mat is legitimately anywhere in a band around 6.4 mm.

IEC 61111 gives no nominal-plus-tolerance figure for thickness; it gives the recommended value and the maximum allowed, which is the window described above.

The consequence shows up at goods-in inspection. If your receiving inspector measures a 6.4 mm mat with a calliper and rejects it for reading 6.1 mm, that rejection is wrong under ASTM and the argument is winnable — but only if the tolerance is on the purchase order. Put it there.

5. Marking, and the colour that does not mean what people think

IEC 61111 requires the marking to carry the manufacturer's identification, the live-working double triangle, the standard reference, the month and year of manufacture, the category where applicable, and the class code.

The colour code applies to the double triangle only: red for Class 0, white for Class 1, yellow for Class 2, green for Class 3, orange for Class 4. It does not encode the class on its own, and it does not replace reading the marking.

At goods-in, read the printed class. Treat the colour as a second check, not the check.

6. Whichever standard you buy to, the clock starts in the storeroom

Under IEC 61111, matting that has gone 12 months without being used has to be examined and electrically tested before it goes into service — and unused stock still in its wrapping counts. The test voltage steps with the class: a visual examination only at Class 0, then 10 kV at Class 1, 20 kV at Class 2, 30 kV at Class 3 and 40 kV at Class 4, each held for a minute.

That rule catches people at stocktake, because a storeroom of wrapped matting looks like a storeroom of new product. If you want the class-by-class detail, it is in the classes article.

7. When the tender names only one standard

Buy to the one it names. Do not quietly substitute the other.

Two things go wrong when you do. First, if you upgrade an IEC spec to the ASTM thickness for the same class, you pay for material the project did not ask for — on a large substation that is real money in freight alone. Second, and worse, if you ship the IEC thickness against an ASTM-named spec, the inspector's table will not recognise it, and the mat is non-conforming even though it is the better-engineered part.

Ask the buyer. If the standard was copied from another project and nobody there can say why, that is a five-minute conversation that saves a container.

8. Writing a spec that survives inspection

Five lines are enough:

  1. 1Standard and edition — IEC 61111:2009 or ASTM D178, named explicitly
  2. 2Class — 0 to 4, and the maximum use voltage you are working to
  3. 3Thickness — the window under IEC, or the nominal plus the ASTM tolerance
  4. 4Type or Category — IIB if you need flame retardance, IIC if the site is oily, C if it is cold
  5. 5Test document — a batch test report travelling with the goods, or a type test report, and whether a third-party report is required

That last line costs the most when it is left off, because a batch report and a type report are different documents and the difference usually surfaces when an inspector asks for the wrong one.

9. When a project genuinely needs both

Multi-country EPC work does exist where the client's standard is IEC and the end user's regulator expects ASTM. In that case the mat has to satisfy the thicker thickness rule for the class and carry both markings.

Call it what it is: dual compliance is a thickness decision as much as a paperwork decision. Say so at the quotation stage rather than after the drawing is approved.

What we supply

Our matting is manufactured to IEC 61111 and ASTM D178, in 5 kV, 10 kV and 35 kV classes, supplied as rolls or cut sheets to the dimensions on the order. Every batch is dielectric tested before dispatch and the batch report travels with the shipment; third-party testing through SGS or TUV can be arranged on request.

If you are working out which standard your project actually names, send us the tender clause and we will tell you which class and thickness it resolves to — including the cases where the clause contradicts itself.

Need this confirmed against your own installation?

Send us the network voltage, the standard you are specifying against and the ambient conditions. Our engineers will confirm the class, thickness and test report, and reply with lead time.

Ask a technical question
Start Your Project

Let's build your power infrastructure together

Send us your specifications — insulating mats, gloves, voltage detectors, grounding systems or safety tooling projects. Our engineers respond within 24 hours with technical recommendations and pricing.